Federal Court Judge Upholds Canada Immigration’s Entry to Canada Refusal for UK MP

By Michael Niren March 31, 2009 2 min. read

UK MP denied entry to Canada, decision upheld

As it turned out, Mr. Galloway, the British MP’s plight for entering Canada ended yesterday as Federal Court Judge Marineau upheld the decision by Canada Immigration to deny his entry to Canada for speaking engagements.

The Court found that Mr. Galloway would not suffer “irreparable harm” as a result of Canada Immigration’s decision to refuse his entry to Canada. Further, the Court held that since the MP had not actually attempted to enter Canada by appearing at our borders,  a final decision on his inadmissibility was not made.

In my view, the Court in its decision, took the pragmatic path, taking a narrow, technical approach to a case where larger democratic principles of free speech and mobility rights could have been upheld. Yes, it is true that “technically” Mr. Galloway himself may not have suffered irreparable harm in not being able to come to Canada to speak. In fact, he was able to address a much wider audience via video conference from New York than he would have had he been admitted to Canada. (Another illustration of the futility of censorship: The controversy popularized his cause and video technology delivered his message.)

And yes, it may also be the case that the Canadian Border Services Agency (CBSA) has not had the opportunity to deny his entry to Canada and detain him at a Canada port of entry in order for there to be “final decision” on his admissibility to Canada .

However, there are larger issues at stake here and the Court should have taken the high road. This case now sets a ominous precedent for the government to bar entry to Canada to anyone it deems undesirable in terms of political opinion.  As mentioned in yesterday’s blog, there is no debate about the questionable moral character of Mr. Galloway who sympathies clearly lie with anti-Israel causes.  But it is the very essence of a free and democratic society that it is able to tolerate such persons while not endorsing their views.

While the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms applies only to Canadian citizens or permanent residence in terms of freedom of speech and mobility rights, the ability of the Canadian government to deny entry to Canada to foreign nationals who are not criminals nor terrorists, is concerning. After all, the United States, a country vilified by Hamas and other terrorist organizations, admitted Mr. Galloway where he was able to exercise his freedom of speech. That is democracy in action. Canada, sadly did not make the grade.

Now the only remedy for Mr. Galloway to enter Canada is to apply for a Temporary Resident Permit (TRP) which, if approved, would allow him to enter Canada as an inadmissible person. Given the Court’s decision, I do not see Mr. Galloway being a likely candidate for a TRP. I guess he will have to continue to address his Canadian audience and beyond by video. I am sure YouTube is ready and willing to oblige.

Ljiljana Pavkov Avatar

Ljiljana Pavkov

I have nothing but praise! The entire team was extremely professional, knowledgeable, and kind, especially Mansi Sanghiv. She patiently explained everything I needed to know and resolved all of my concerns. I felt safe and well taken care of throughout the entire process. I am extremely satisfied with the service and experience, and I wholeheartedly recommend them to anyone looking for quality, dedication, and trust.

Lisanne Cholette Avatar

Lisanne Cholette

Mansi has been helping me navigate through a new chapter in my life. It has been a huge comfort to be able to lean on her knowledge and expertise and I would highly recommend her to anyone!

BERLITA COLLADO Avatar

BERLITA COLLADO

I am so very thankful to the VISAPACE team for making it all come true and possible from my Open Work Permit to my Permanent Residence, you make it all happen .Thank you very much from the bottom of my heart , Thank you for being part of my achievements. Now I am now a Permanent Residence through the effort, power and knowledge of VISAPLACE LEGAL TEAM.
Sending you my best appreciation and thank you.

Berlie Collado

Shahrzad Sh Avatar

Shahrzad Sh

“I truly want to thank Mansi. Her patience and thoughtful advices made a big difference for me. Her recommendations were not only helpful but also gave me clearer insight. Words can’t fully express how grateful I am for her support.”

kevin geoffrey Avatar

kevin geoffrey

Visa place helped me with my daughter’s sponsorship 3 years ago. Last week I contacted them for some clarification on a different matter. It was about an issue which technically was a problem of CIC’s software glitch and had nothing to do with Visa Place.
Yet Reena Sandu was assigned for my case. she helped me with enthusiasm and showed no hesitation despite me being an ex-client from 3 years ago.
I was very happy that even after 3 years of finishing business, Visa Place were respectful of their clients. Special thanks again to Reena for her enthusiasm and support.

Nessie Leigh Ilarde Avatar

Nessie Leigh Ilarde

Thank you very much for helping me get my new visa! I appreciate Ms. Felicita and her colleagues for guiding us through the process making sure that everything is precise. Highly recommend your firm. Thanks again 🙂

parker ellis Avatar

parker ellis

Mansi Sanghvi has been nothing for of remarkable for me. I have been dealing with a visa, immigration issues , and any time I have to call her, she has been there to answer any questions. Has answers to every question and is there to HELP YOU. Truly could not recommend her more.